GTSC's National Preparedness Month Symposium
Presentation: Government Contracts & Insurance Issues: How Prepared is Your Company?
Presenter: Justin Chiarodo, Partner, Dickstein Shapiro LLP; John Gibbons, Partner, Dickstein Shapiro LLP
Description: Disasters require advance planning to protect your business. Beyond physical preparedness for a disaster or terrorist attack, your firm should pay close attention to its assets – and how your company can best leverage them. This panel will discuss both government contracts and insurance considerations relating to disasters.
3. FEMA Disaster Assistance
• Pursuant to the Stafford Act,
FEMA provides funding to
state and local governments
– Known as the Public Assistance
Grant Program
– Federal requirements may
apply to these contracts
– There must be a “major
disaster” or “emergency”
declaration by the President for
FEMA to provide funding
3
4. FEMA Disaster Assistance
• Federal assistance may include:
– Debris removal
– Housing, transportation, medical, legal assistance to individuals
– Search and rescue
– Repair and replacement of damaged facilities
• Federal assistance may be provided:
– Directly from the federal government
– Through federal contracts
– Through state and local governments and/or private organizations
using federal funds furnished through cost-sharing arrangements,
grants, and loans
4
5. FEMA Cost Sharing
• Typical cost sharing under the Stafford Act:
– 75% Federal / 25% State funding
• Federal share may be increased to 90% when a disaster is
particularly severe and may even be increased to 100% for a
limited time period
• Contract may be administered by a federal agency or a
state/local government agency
• Federal rules and regulations may apply, even when the
contract is issued by a state/local agency
5
6. FEMA Disaster Assistance
Disaster Event Occurs
Governor Requests FEMA
Assistance
Disaster/Emergency Declaration
Issued
FEMA Awards Grant to State
State/Local Government Awards
Contracts for Disaster Relief
6
7. FEMA Disaster Assistance
Major Disaster
• Any natural catastrophe or
fire, flood, or explosion,
which in the determination
of the president, causes
damage of sufficient severity
and magnitude to warrant
major disaster assistance
under the Stafford Act
• Focus is on both immediate
and longer-term needs
Emergency
• Any instance in which federal
assistance is needed to
supplement state and local
efforts and capabilities to
save lives and to protect
property and public health
and safety, or to lessen or
avert the threat of
catastrophe
• Focus is on immediate needs
7
11. Stafford Act Local Preferences
• Stafford Act contracts may either be:
– Set-aside for local contractors (i.e., non-local contractors cannot
compete as a prime, but may serve as a subcontractor)
– Or local contractors must be given a preference in the evaluation
scheme (but non-local contractors typically can still compete)
• The RFP should define who is a “local” contractor
• When contracts are set-aside for local contractors, the
contract may limit subcontracting to non-local contractors
(see FAR 52.226-5)
• Contracts for services: at least 50% of the cost of personnel
must be spent on employees of businesses within the local
area
11
12. Katrina Task Force = Increased Oversight
• Congressional Task Force examined Katrina response
– Contracting urgency in wake of storm led to inadequate oversight
– Need for more trained procurement professionals
– Ambiguous guidance regarding local contractor preferences
• Has resulted in increased oversight of FEMA spending
– High profile disasters/emergencies receiving scrutiny by Congress, the
media, GAO, etc.
– Focus on transparency, advance planning, and preventing fraud and
abuse
– Heightened scrutiny for contractors
12
13. High Stakes in Disaster Fraud Cases
• Disaster fraud post-Katrina estimated to reach $6 billion
• January 2008 – Emergency and Disaster Assistance Fraud
Penalty Enhancement Act
• $4 million settlement agreement in FCA suit involving
Lighthouse Disaster Relief and its partners
– Government alleged that Lighthouse accepted payment for work that
was not completely performed
– Also alleged false statements to FEMA for early payment
13
14. Compliance Tips
• Carefully review your RFPs and
relevant guidance (e.g., local
preferences)
• Keep great written records of
compliance
• Vet your teaming partners
• Consult legal and/or contracts
professionals with questions
14
17. First Party Insurance
• Private Insurance and Public Assistance
• Private Third Party Insurance insures against loss of, or
damages to, policyholder’s property (and lost business
revenue)
• Examples: Business Property, Contingent BI
• Fires, Natural Disasters, 9/11, Hurricanes
• Other Specialized Types of Coverage
17
18. First Party Insurance
• Issues frequently disputed between insureds and insurers
– How do deductibles and the self-insured retentions work?
– How do your limits and sub-limits work?
– Does your property coverage match the value of your property?
– Coinsurance?
– Business interruption?
– Contingent Business Interruption?
– Civil Authority Coverage?
– Ingress/Egress?
– Service Interruption?
– Dispute resolution?
18
19. Be Prepared
• Have insurance information available
• Checklists
• Document, document, document
19
20. Questions?
• Justin A. Chiarodo | Partner
DICKSTEINSHAPIROLLP
1825 Eye Street NW | Washington, DC 20006
Tel (202) 420-2706 | Fax (202) 420-2201
chiarodoj@dicksteinshapiro.com
• John Gibbons| Partner
DICKSTEINSHAPIROLLP
1825 Eye Street NW | Washington, DC 20006
Tel (202) 420-3644 | Fax (202) 420-2201
gibbonsj@dicksteinshapiro.com
20